Crime Score for Herkimer County, NY
County FIPS 36043 · New York · July 2026 snapshot · powered by SpotCrime
Higher crime than 32.86% of US counties
National rank
#7,303
of 735 scored counties
New York rank
#59
in state
Score index
46.3
crime intensity
Scored ZIPs
11
in this county
Herkimer County in New York scored in the 32.9th percentile for reported crime among US counties in July 2026. That is a Below Average rating, below the national midpoint for reported crime. It ranks #7,303 nationally and #59 in New York.
Within the county, 11 ZIP codes have published scores. Their median is the 50.2th percentile; the highest is 13304 at 68.53 and the lowest is 13438 at 27.39. A county score summarises the whole area, so a ZIP inside it can sit well above or below it.
ZIP codes in Herkimer County, ranked
- 113304BarneveldAbove Average68.53
- 213431PolandAbove Average67.76
- 313322ClayvilleAbove Average66.98
- 413367CastorlandAbove Average64.82
- 513324Cold BrookAbove Average57.82
- 613501UticaAbove Average50.17
- 713502UticaBelow Average49.02
- 813413ChadwicksBelow Average47.70
- 913456ClayvilleBelow Average38.10
- 1013338Otter LakeBelow Average36.11
- 1113438RemsenBelow Average27.39
Data: CrimeScore by SpotCrime. Scores describe areas, not people, and are not predictions. Terms.